|
|
||||||||
Ann Thorac Surg 2005;79:234-240
© 2005 The Society of Thoracic Surgeons
a Department of Thoracic Surgery European Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy
b Department of Pathology, European Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy
c Department of Medical Oncology, European Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy
d Department of Radiotherapy, European Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy
Accepted for publication June 16, 2004.
* Address reprint requests to Dr Spaggiari, Department of Thoracic Surgery, European Institute of Oncology, Via Ripamonti 435, 20141Milan, Italy (E-mail: lorenzo.spaggiari{at}ieo.it).
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS: From November 1996 to December 2003, 15 patients underwent extended pneumonectomy with partial resection of the left atrium for lung cancer, without cardiopulmonary bypass.
RESULTS: Of the 15 patients (median age of 63 years, range 35 to 74 years), 11 were men (73%) and 4 were women. Six patients (40%) underwent preoperative invasive mediastinal staging. Nine patients (60%) underwent induction chemotherapy. Nine patients (60%) underwent right pneumonectomy. Pathologic analysis of the specimens identified 8 patients (53%) with N2 disease, 5 patients (33%) with N1 disease, and 2 patients with N0 disease. The T status was T4 in 10 patients, pT3 in 3 patients, and T0 in the remaining 2 patients. The were 10 squamous cell carcinomas (60%), 2 adenocarcinomas, 1 adenosquamous carcinoma, 1 mucoepidermoid carcinoma, and 1 atypical carcinoid tumor. The median intensive care unit and hospital stay were 1 day and 6.4 days, respectively. There were only two (15.3%) minor postoperative complications (atrial arrhythmias), which were successfully treated medically. There was no postoperative mortality. At completion of the study, 9 patients (60%) were still alive, with 8 showing no evidence of disease. The remaining 6 patients died because of systemic recurrences. The 3-year probability of survival was 39%.
CONCLUSIONS: Extended pneumonectomy with partial resection of the left atrium for advanced lung cancer is a feasible procedure, with low postoperative morbidity and mortality. In fact, it can lead to excellent local control of the disease, if not to a permanent cure in select patients.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
First of all, a clarification of the term left atrium resection is mandatory. In our opinion, the true left atrium resection is an extended resection involving the heart, with part of the muscular wall of the left atrium included in the specimen. Resection at the origin of the pulmonary veins, which involves clamping of the left atrium, should not be considered an extended resection involving the heart.
Second, the key, open questions that deal with the technical aspects and their impact in terms of postoperative outcome as well as the oncologic benefits of such an extended surgery in curing this disease need to be addressed.
Without procedural distinctions and a suitable number of patients on which to perform statistical comparisons, no conclusive assessments regarding the real impact of such an extended surgery can be made. Therefore, this study has a threefold purpose: first, to describe the technique used in this extended resection; second, to evaluate morbidity and mortality of the series; and third, to present midterm survival data.
| Material and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Patients were studied preoperatively by total-body computed tomography (CT) scan, lung perfusion scan, echocardiography, and in the more recent patients, by positron emission tomography (PET) scan and intraoperative transesophageal echocardiography (TEE). Patients with mediastinal lymph nodes greater than 1 cm, or PET-positive in the paratracheal or subcarinal regions, or both, underwent cervical mediastinoscopy. If pleural effusion was suspected, preoperative thoracoscopy was performed to exclude carcinosis.
Our selection criteria for extended pneumonectomy with partial resection of the left atrium were: (1) patients younger than 75 years of age, (2) patients who were motivated and fully informed about the proposed surgery, and (3) a thorough, cardiorespiratory evaluation. Patients were excluded if they presented with cardiac diseases, chronic renal and hepatic insufficiencies, or a predicted postoperative forced expiratory volume in 1 second of less than 40%.
Our oncologic criteria were:
The rationale for doing induction chemotherapy was (1) in the presence of positive (at mediastinoscopy) mediastinal lymph nodes in stations R4 and 7, induction chemotherapy improves survival among this group of patients, based on data derived from stage IIIA (ie, sterilized systemic micrometastases in patients with positive lymph nodes); and (2) induction chemotherapy decreases large disease from invading the left atrium, thus reducing the risk of incomplete resection or nonresectability at preoperative thoracic CT.
Preoperative pathologic confirmation of atrial infiltration is impossible with a minimally invasive approach, because it is necessary to perform a biopsy of the heart for the histologic confirmation that tumor is within the atrial wall (T4). Therefore, the criteria used for documenting direct invasion of the left atrium (T4) were clinical. Specifically, T4 status was clinically documented by using a spiral chest CT scan (Fig 1).
|
Technique
All patients were resected without CPB. The operation was carefully planned, based on preoperative data from the chest CT scan, to better analyze the feasibility of resecting the atrial wall. For right side tumors in particular, it is important to take into consideration the length of the interatrial groove and the distance of the tumor from the origin of the contralateral pulmonary veins in order to maintain sufficient space and avoid occluding veins during clamping (Fig 1).
If the patient is a candidate for left atrium resection, the preferred approach is a full posterolateral thoracotomy. Before beginning the pneumonectomy, the pericardium is fully opened in order to identify the extent of atrial involvement. The origin of the contralateral veins is also identified, again in order to avoid their occlusion during clamping.
For anatomic reasons, right side tumors can invade the left atrium quickly and diffusely owing to the shortness of the right upper pulmonary vein. To increase the length of the right atrial cuff, the epicardium between the right and left atrium (the interatrial groove) is carefully dissected so that the left atrial cuff can be lengthened to about 2 cm. This procedure, the Sondergaard technique, [2] is more evident in the upper part of the left atrium, near the superior vena cava (Fig 2). It increases the margin of resection; thus, the risk of clamping the right atrium during the operation is avoided. A large Satinsky clamp is then put in place to evaluate the surgical feasibility of atrial resection and to observe the cardiocirculatory ef-fects of atrial volume reduction (Fig 3). During this preliminary clamping, the TEE permits cardiac alterations to be monitored.
|
|
|
|
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The pathologic nodal status was N2 in 8 patients (53%), N1 in 5 patients (33%), and N0 in the remaining 2 patients. The pathologic T status was T4 (histologic evidence of the tumor within the atrial wall) in 10 patients. The remaining 5 patients underwent chemotherapy before extended pneumonectomy. Three demonstrated T3 disease in which there was no histologic presence of the tumor within the atrial wall, but infiltration was noted at the origin of the pulmonary veins; thus, an atrial wall resection was required to achieve a complete resection. The remaining 2 patients demonstrated a complete response (T0) (no evidence of disease in the specimen). Before induction chemotherapy, all 5 of these patients were considered cT4, based on the criteria previously reported. According to our clinical criteria for defining T status, 70% of the cases thus had a pathologic confirmation of atrial involvement.
All patients underwent complete resection (no positive margin after resection). After pneumonectomy, there were 10 squamous cell carcinomas (60%), 2 adenocarcinomas, 1 adenosquamous carcinoma, 1 mucoepidermoid carcinoma, and 1 atypical carcinoid tumor. These last two patients had a preoperative diagnosis of NSCLC and were therefore included in the analysis of postoperative outcome (intent to treat). However, they were expected to demonstrate a different long-term outcome and thus were eliminated from the survival analysis.
The median intensive care unit stay and hospital stay of the overall series was 1 day and 6.4 days, respectively. There were only two (15.3%) minor postoperative complications (atrial arrhythmias), which were successfully treated medically. No postoperative deaths occurred. Adjuvant radiotherapy was performed on 5 patients.
All patients were followed-up within a median of 16.5 months, ranging from 2 to 45 months. At the completion of the study, 9 patients (60%) were still alive, of whom 8 had no evidence of disease. Local control was excellent (0% local recurrence), and those patients who died did so because of systemic recurrences.
Survival was calculated according to the Kaplan-Meier method (except for the 2 patients with mucoepidermoid carcinoma and atypical carcinoid tumor), with the 3-year probability of survival at 39% (Fig 6). The number of patients at risk at 1-, 2-, and 3-years were 12, 11, and 9, respectively.
|
| Comment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
With regards to the technical aspects, one of the most viable ways to reach standardized results is through differentiation between the true atrial resection, characterized by the presence of a large piece of the atrial wall in the specimen that indicates a large infiltration by the tumor (T4 disease) (Fig 7), and the intrapericardial pneumonectomy that involves clamping the left atrium to allow resection for T3 disease at the origin of the pulmonary veins. We do not believe that the latter should be considered an extended resection involving the left atrium.
|
|
|
The atrial-clamping technique is not difficult to perform, but it could cause hemodynamic instability if the resection is not adequate (too large of an atrial volume reduction or occlusion of the contralateral vein). An alternative to this simple clamping technique could be the use of total CPB. However, this procedure is rarely used, and at present, reports on only a few patients have been published [5, 6].
Supporting CPB is that (1) it may facilitate resection with a subsequent reconstruction of the wall using a patch, thus reducing the risk of both hemodynamic instability and tumor fragmentation with subsequent embolization, and (2) during the operation, frozen-section analyses can done on the atrial margins to avoid incomplete resections.
However, cardiocirculatory arrest and its complications are associated with high risk in patients who require pneumonectomy. In fact, it has been suggested that CPB may reduce survival in patients with lung cancer [7] because its use may, theoretically, facilitate metastasization in that the need for blood transfusions and the activation of various cellular inflammatory systems decrease the patient's immune system. CPB may also increase the risk of acute respiratory distress syndrome in patients requiring pneumonectomy because of increased blood transfusions, heparinization, and the use of large volumes of saline solution, as well as increase the risk of postoperative hemothorax.
In our experience, no hemodynamic problems were recorded with the direct clamping technique, either during or after resection. An echocardiography performed on the more recent patients before their discharge did identify an increase in pulmonary artery pressure, but with no clinical significance. As long as preoperative selection is detailed and accurate, postoperative morbidity and mortality will be low, suggesting that this surgery can be safely performed. Right pneumonectomies are more frequently performed than left pneumonectomies. The reason for this is probably due to the anatomic characteristic of the left lung: the presence of the aortic arch and the position of the heart may contraindicate resection because the neoplasm could quickly infiltrate the multiorgans (aorta, heart, left atrium, etc.) (Fig 5).
With regards to the oncologic aspects, in our previous analysis (personal communication, Regnard JF, Spaggiari L, 8eme Journee de Pathologie Thoracique, Hopital Marie Lannelongue, Paris, 29 Mars 1996) that covered a 12-year period, the results from extended surgical resection with partial resection of the left atrium were disappointing (5-year survival, 19%; 11% in N2 patients). Most likely, these disappointing results were derived, in part, from an out-of-date patient selection; plus, only a small number of patients in that series underwent induction chemotherapy.
In the recent literature, Tsuchiya [8] reported on the largest study to date (in 1994) concerning this extended surgery. All 44 patients underwent left atrium resection, without CPB, with only a vascular clamp. The defect was then sutured directly. Only 7 patients (16%) survived for more than 3 years, and 3 of these had T3 disease. Fukuse and colleagues [9] later reported on 14 patients who underwent left atrium resection, with a median survival of 10 months.
Apart from these recent experiences and a few others with a very limited number of patients [10, 11], no other occurrences involving this surgery are available, leaving this surgery still anecdotal. However, these limited experiences do demonstrate that in select patients, extended pneumonectomy with partial resection of the left atrium may improve local control, with a permanent cure in some cases.
Sixty percent of the patients in our study underwent induction chemotherapy; however, 53% of patients still showed N2 disease even after induction chemotherapy, proving that in these patients, the percentage of mediastinal lymph node involvement was high. Induction chemoradiotherapy was never used in this series. The rationale for excluding radiotherapy was to limit the heart toxicity derived from high-dose radiotherapy before surgery. Yet, radiotherapy was indicated in those patients positive for highest mediastinal lymph nodes after resection. Even with the tumor's advanced stage, the results after complete surgery in terms of the rate of local recurrence were excellent. And the 3-year probability of survival of 39% confirmed the validity of this extended resection in treating such an extended disease. However, taking into account the small number of patients in the present series, no definitive conclusions can be made. In fact, questions concerning the role of induction chemotherapy and surgical resection for N2 disease are still open.
Based on our preliminary results, we suggest a preoperative mediastinoscopy be performed on all patients with left atrium involvement to exclude diffuse (R2) mediastinal lymph node involvement. All patients should then undergo preoperative chemotherapy. Intraoperative echocardiography should also be performed before resection to identify the risk of hemodynamic complications.
We conclude that if carefully evaluated, involvement of the left atrium need not be considered an absolute contraindication to surgical resection. In fact, in highly selected patients, extended pneumonectomy with partial resection of the left atrium can provide excellent local control of the disease, and even lead to a definitive cure in some patients.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
K. R. Shen, B. F. Meyers, J. M. Larner, and D. R. Jones Special Treatment Issues in Lung Cancer: ACCP Evidence-Based Clinical Practice Guidelines (2nd Edition) Chest, September 1, 2007; 132(3_suppl): 290S - 305S. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |