|
|
||||||||
Ann Thorac Surg 2002;74:1917-1922
© 2002 The Society of Thoracic Surgeons
a Department of Visceral and Vascular Surgery, University of Cologne, Cologne, Germany
Accepted for publication July 2, 2002.
* Address reprint requests to Dr Schröder, Department of Visceral and Vascular Surgery, University of Cologne, Joseph-Stelzmann Str 9, 50931 Cologne, Germany.
e-mail: wolfgang.schroeder{at}uni-koeln.de
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
METHODS: Forty-seven patients with esophageal cancer underwent esophagectomy and gastric tube formation with intrathoracic esophagogastrostomy. Postoperatively, mucosal pCO2 of the gastric tube (pCO2i) was measured using continuous tonometry (TONOCAP, Datex Ohmeda). pCO2i was related to the arterial pCO2 (
pCO2 = pCO2i - pCO2a).
RESULTS: A total of 4,338
pCO2 measurements were recorded. On average, the pCO2i of each patient was monitored over a period of 92 hours. In 5 patients an anastomotic leakage of the esophagogastrostomy developed. The mean
pCO2 of this group was 31.7 mm Hg (±19.3 SD) and significantly higher (p < 0.0001) than that of patients without anastomotic leakage (20.7 mm Hg ± 12.8 SD). With a
pCO2 cut-off point of 56 mm Hg measured for 5 hours, the sensitivity was 0.8, the specifity 0.9, and the positive predictive value 0.5. In patients with anastomotic leakage, the peak
pCO2 preceded clinical symptoms. False positive
pCO2 measurements (n = 4) were mainly due to severe pneumonia with long-term ventilation.
CONCLUSIONS: Mucosal pCO2 measurement of the gastric tube can be used as an early indicator of a complicated postoperative course predicting anastomotic leakage of the esophagogastrostomy.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Tonometry is defined as measurement of the partial carbon dioxide pressure in the gastric mucosa (pCO2i, in mm Hg), and has been used as an index of splanchnic perfusion in critically ill patients [1113]. Two intraoperative studies could demonstrate that continuous pCO2i measurement is a valid method of detecting microcirculatory changes during formation of a gastric tube after esophagectomy [7, 8].
Therefore the question of this study was whether continuous pCO2i measurement can be used to monitor microcirculation of the gastric conduit during the postoperative course and to detect those patients who develop an anastomotic leakage.
| Patients and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Surgery
In all 47 patients a standardized transthoracic esophagectomy with two-field lymphadenectomy of the abdominal and mediastinal compartment was performed [14].
After laparotomy and opening of the hiatus the resectability of the primary tumor and the absence of distant metastases were reconfirmed. The duodenum was mobilized by an extensive Kocher maneuver followed by dissection of the gastrocolic ligament with maintenance of the right gastroepiploic artery along the greater curvature. The right gastric artery was preserved. In addition, partial en-bloc lymphadenectomy of abdominal compartment II was performed. Before closure of the abdomen the pylorus was mechanically dilated and gastric tube formation was commenced by placing one linear stapler at the lesser curvature between the middle and distal third.
After moving the patient into a left lateral position, an anterolateral thoracotomy through the fifth intercostal space was performed, followed by an en-bloc resection of the esophagus with dissection of the azygos vein and thoracic duct. Lymph node dissection of the upper mediastinum included the paraesophageal and right-sided paratracheal nodes. The esophagus was transected in the upper mediastinum 5 cm above the azygos vein and the stomach was pulled into the chest. A stapler esophagogastrostomy was performed between the gastric fundus and esophageal stump using a circular stapler (CEEA 28 [Autosuture, Germany]) inserted through the lesser curvature. The procedure was completed by resection of the lesser curvature with the adherent esophagus using a linear stapler (TAA 90, Autosuture). After finishing the intrathoracic anastomosis, a 16F tonometry nasogastric tube with a silicone balloon at its distal end (Datex Ohmeda, Duisburg, Germany) was placed in the gastric conduit. The upper edge of the silicone balloon was positioned 2 cm below the anastomosis under bimanual palpation.
The mean operation time was 395 minutes (range 250 to 560). During the intraoperative and postoperative course, a mean 1.8 U (range 0 to 18 U) packed red blood cells was administered. Twenty-eight of 47 patients (59.6%) required no blood transfusion. In all patients a complete resection of the primary tumor could be achieved (R0 resection).
Postoperative management included treatment in the intensive care unit (ICU) followed by monitoring of the patients course in the intermediate care unit. For statistical analysis this was summarized as "ICU stay." Daily chest roentgenography was performed to check on the correct position of the nasogastric tube and to look for radiologic evidence of pneumonia. Any prolonged mechanical ventilation due to pneumonia was treated by systemic antibiotics and a puncture tracheostomy to ensure an adequate bronchial lavage. Depending on clinical symptoms and the time interval after the operation, endoscopy or contrast swallow, or both, was performed to detect an anastomotic leakage. Routine postoperative contrast radiology was not considered to be useful [17, 18]. A detailed documentation of all postoperative surgical and general complications was carried out.
Postoperative tonometry
Continuous tonometry is based on recirculating gas analysis with a TONOCAP device (Datex Ohmeda, Duisburg, Germany). Recirculating gas analysis requires a silicon balloon with a semipermeable membrane (16F tonometry tube; Datex Ohmeda), which is automatically filled with a defined CO2 concentration by the TONOCAP. After a definite time of equilibration with the mucosal CO2, the gas is automatically sucked out of the balloon. The TONOCAP indirectly measures the mucosal pCO2 from the gradient between mucosal and balloon CO2 concentration. The CO2 concentration is expressed as partial pressure (mm Hg). This cycle is repeated at 15-minute intervals.
Immediately after admission to ICU, pCO2i measurement commenced. According to the manufacturers instruction, calibration of the TONOCAP required three to four cycles of recirculating gas analysis so that pCO2i measurement of the first hour was not included for further analysis. Thereafter, one pCO2i value was documented each hour. An initial chest roentgenogram confirmed the correct position of the nasogastric tube with its silicone balloon below the intrathoracic anastomosis. According to international standards [17, 18], pCO2i was related to the arterial pCO2 (
pCO2 = pCO2i - pCO2a). Arterial pCO2 was obtained by regular blood gas analysis performed at least every 6 hours. All patients received a daily dosage of 40 mg omeprazle intravenously until oral intake on postoperative day 7 to 9 was begun. Postoperative tonometry was performed for as long as the patient required the nasogastric tube for emptying the gastric tube or was treated in the ICU. The decision to remove the nasogastric tube was entirely based on clinical judgment and was not influenced by the study protocol.
The study protocol was approved by the local institutional human research committee (No. 99045, 28 April 1999).
Statistical analysis
Aggregated data are presented using the usual descriptive means. To describe differences between various
pCO2, Students t test for unpaired samples or analysis of variance was used as appropriate. Posthoc analysis of subgroup differences was done using the Scheffe method. A p < 0.05 was considered significant. For the variables "anastomotic leakage" and "septic syndrome," sensitivity, specifity, and predictive value of postoperative
pCO2 as a diagnostic test were calculated from receiver operating characteristics (ROC). The definition of the cut-off point based on the ROC curve included the measurement of the designated
pCO2 for at least 5 hours. All computations were done using SPSS statistical software (version 10; SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Measurement of
pCO2
A total of 4,338
pCO2 measurements with a mean
pCO2 of 22.0 mm Hg (±14.2 SD) was recorded and included for further analysis. Based on an hourly documentation of
pCO2 values the gastric conduit of each patient was monitored over an average period of 92.3 hours (range 17 to 159).
For 42 patients without anastomotic leakage 3,832
pCO2 measurements were analyzed. The histogram of these
pCO2 measurements showed an ordinary distribution with a mean
pCO2 of 20.7 mm Hg (±12.8 SD; Fig 1).
For 5 patients with anastomotic leakage a total of 506
pCO2 values were recorded. The mean
pCO2 in this group was 31.7 mm Hg (±19.3 SD) and significantly higher (p < 0.0001) compared with patients without anastomotic leakage (Fig 1). The optimal cut-off point calculated from ROC curve was a
pCO2 of 56 mm Hg measured for 5 hours (Fig 2).
For this
pCO2 value the sensitivity was 0.8, the specifity 0.9, and the positive predictive value 0.5. The area under the ROC curve was 0.83. For this cut-off point, 4 of 5 patients with anastomotic leakage were identified by continuous tonometry (Table 2). In all 4 patients the defined cut-off point was measured for at least 5 hours and observed within the first 48 hours after the operation. This was before the clinical diagnosis of an anastomotic leak was suspected (Table 2). One patient did not fulfill the
pCO2 criteria of anastomotic leakage and was considered to be falsely negative.
|
|
In 22 patients who had radiologic or microbiologic evidence, or both, of pneumonia during the postoperative course, a total of 2,263
pCO2 measurements with a mean of 22.3 mm Hg ± 14.2 SD was recorded. For 25 patients without postoperative pneumonia (2075
pCO2 measurements), the mean
pCO2 was not different (21.7 mm Hg ± 14.2 SD). In 5 patients with a septic syndrome and multiple organ failure, the mean
pCO2 of 470 recorded
pCO2 measurements was 26.4 mm Hg ± 15.9 SD. This was significantly different (p < 0.0001) from the 42 patients who had no septic complication during the postoperative course (3868
pCO2 measurements, mean
pCO2 21.5 mm Hg ± 13.8 SD). For the variable "septic syndrome," the cut-off point of 56 mm Hg measured for 5 hours revealed a sensitivity of 0.6, a specifity of 0.88, and a positive predictive value of 0.36. The area under the ROC curve was calculated as 0.76.
For analysis of pCO2 measurement before and after extubation, 5 of 47 patients had to be excluded as mechanical ventilation exceeded postoperative pCO2 measurement, so that no
pCO2 values were obtained after extubation. In 42 patients all
pCO2 measurements obtained during postoperative mechanical ventilation (n = 819) were compared with the first 7
pCO2 measurements after extubation (approximately 7 hours) during spontaneous ventilation (n = 294). In 27 of 42 patients (64.3%) there was a significant increase of pCO2 measurement after extubation. The mean
pCO2 during mechanical ventilation (15.1 mm Hg ± 10.8 SD) was significantly lower (p < 0.0001) compared with the mean
pCO2 (23.4 mm Hg ± 14.9 SD) after extubation.
| Comment |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This study was conducted to evaluate continuous pCO2i measurement as a method of postoperative monitoring of the gastric conduit. In contrast to other methods [9] the simple clinical application of continuous tonometry is striking as it requires only the positioning of an intraluminal nasogastric tubea procedure performed by most surgeons to splint the esophagogastrostomy and to empty the gastric tube postoperatively. From this point of view pCO2i measurement appears to be a favorable method of monitoring that can also be applied outside of an ICU. In previous studies tonometry was used to predict the outcome of ICU patients with a broad variety of different clinical diagnoses [1113]. The general principle of continuous tonometry is based on the indirect measurement of mucosal pCO2, which is used as an index of splanchnic perfusion [17, 18]. Splanchnic hypoperfusion results in an increase of cellular pCO2 by two mechanisms. First, hypoperfusion induces a switch from aerobic to anaerobic metabolism with increased production of mucosal pCO2. Second, hypoperfusion reduces the "washout" of mucosal pCO2, which then accumulates in the gastric mucosa. According to international standards adequate mucosal pCO2 measurement is performed as automated recirculating gas analysis, which has proved to be more sensitive than gastric saline tonometry [17, 18]. Furthermore, pCO2i measurement is related either to end-expiratory pCO2 (pCO2e) or arterial pCO2 (pCO2a) in order to exclude the influence of pulmonary or hemodynamic factors [17, 18]. This
pCO2 is known to be superior to the mucosal pH (pHi) calculation because it does not depend on intra and extracellular bicarbonate concentration [17, 18]. Because
pCO2 values also reflect the actual pCO2a, the measurement of other variables such as mixed venous saturation or cardiac index seems to be unnecessary. All these requirements of adequate pCO2i measurement are fulfilled in this clinical study. The influence of H2 blockers or proton pump inhibitors on pCO2i measurement is still not known and a matter of controversial discussion [17, 18].
In the case of gastric tube formation, hypoperfusion in the critical region of the gastric fundus is induced by partial devascularization of the lesser curvature. This surgical procedure also reduces the integrity of the intramural capillary network [4]. Two clinical studies demonstrated that continuous tonometry is a valid method of detecting pCO2i changes associated with gastric tube formation [7, 8]. Both studies reported a remarkable increase of pCO2i during the operative procedure.
This is the first clinical study that investigates continuous tonometry as a method of monitoring the gastric tube during the postoperative course. A large series of 47 patients with an esophageal carcinoma was included. All patients underwent a transthoracic esophagectomy. The reconstruction was performed by a standardized gastric tube with intrathoracic esophagogastrostomy. It is remarkable that in almost all patientseven patients with an uncomplicated postoperative coursethe pCO2i measurement was clearly elevated when compared with the arterial pCO2. Such an obvious gap between arterial and mucosal pCO2 has not been described for any other patient group of other studies, indicating that increased
pCO2 values are not a prognostic factor for ICU patients in general.
Another phenomenon detected with continuous tonometry is that microcirculation of the gastric conduit deteriorates during the time of extubation, which can be explained by two physiologic mechanisms. First, extubation is associated with the release of endogenous catecholamines, which might cause vasoconstriction and consecutive hypoperfusion of the splanchnic region. Secondly, extubation is associated with an increase in abdominal muscle tension, causing elevated abdominal pressure. This increases the duodenogastric reflux of alkaline juice so that bicarbonate neutralizes H+ ions, resulting in an increased concentration of luminal pCO2. Since the gastric interponate is vagotomized, it is unlikely that gastric mucosa still generates H+ ions in the early postoperative course. Therefore the increase in mucosal pCO2 after extubation seems to be a true accumulation resulting from endogenous vasoconstrictors and hypoperfusion. The clinical consequence is to be aware of the decreased perfusion in the gastric interponate during extubation and to reduce the patients postoperative stress by adequate administration of analgetics.
The high rate of pulmonary complications can be explained through a very detailed and thorough documentation, including even patients with radiologic suspicion of pneumonia. An early indication for tracheostomy is part of a consequent ICU management for these patients, resulting in overall low mortality. In this series 5 of 47 patients developed an anastomotic leakage during the postoperative course. This complication rate is comparable with that of other recent reports on intrathoracic esophagogastrostomy [16]. To identify patients with this complication the establishment of an appropriate
pCO2 cut-off point is important. Assuming that only a hypoperfusion of a longer period can cause an anastomotic leakage, the designated cut-off point had to be measured for at least 5 hours. Based on this time interval and ROC analysis a
pCO2 of 56 mm Hg identified 4 of 5 patients as having an anastomotic problem. It is of major interest that in all 4 patients identified with continuous tonometry the peak
pCO2 measurement occurred clearly before the clinical manifestation of the anastomotic leakage. This appears to be the real advantage of continuous pCO2i measurementthat it serves as an early diagnostic indicator of anastomotic leakage. Therefore it may help to reduce morbidity and mortality associated with this surgical complication.
One patient with an early anastomotic leak on postoperative day 5 was not detected by mucosal pCO2 measurement. At the time of diagnosis, endoscopy revealed a small leak but a well-perfused mucosa of the gastric interponate. This patient clearly demonstrates the limitations of continuous tonometry with false negative results in case of technically defective anastomoses of an otherwise well-perfused interponate. In addition, improper positioning of the silicon balloon in the antrum or even in the corpus can cause false negative results when pCO2i measurement is obtained from well-perfused gastric regions and not the important anastomotic region in the fundus.
Four patients were classified as false positive without developing an anastomotic leakage during the postoperative course. Three of these patients had prolonged ICU treatment owing to pulmonary and septic complications. In this respect continuous tonometry fulfills its task as an index of splanchnic perfusion and predictor of the general outcome of ICU patients, as has been demonstrated in other studies [1113]. It is of major importance that for patients with an anastomotic leakage as well as for the false positive patients the
pCO2 peak was measured within the first 48 hours. This means that postoperative continuous tonometry limited to this interval still detects the patients of interest.
In summary, the results of this study suggest that continuous tonometry helps to identify patients in the early postoperative stage who are at risk of developing an anastomotic leakage of esophagogastrostomy during the postoperative course. For clinical purposes the cut-off point can be chosen at
pCO2 50 mm Hg. The clinical consequence for patients presenting
pCO2 values beyond this cut-off point needs to be discussed. As increased
pCO2 levels occur before clinical manifestation of the primary complication, diagnostic and therapeutic strategies can be modified in order to prevent secondary complications. Therefore an early diagnostic workup of these patients is recommended considering that partial ischemia of the gastric tube might cause a fatal outcome. This diagnostic procedure includes contrast swallow or endoscopy, or both, which can be safely performed even in the very early postoperative course [15, 16]. In case of an unremarkable gastric tube without evidence of any anastomotic problem, very careful clinical observation seems mandatory because
pCO2 levels beyond the cut-off point are associated with a complicated and prolonged postoperative course in almost all patients.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. Kant Gastric tip necrosis Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., August 1, 2005; 28(2): 359 - 359. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |